We keep hiring VPs of Sales who leave in 90 days. What should we do?

If you keep hiring VPs of Sales who leave in 90 days, stop hiring and fix the seat first. I'm Tal Paperin, a fractional CRO. I take the empty seat and own the number while I rebuild the sales motion. Then you hire a VP into a job that can be won. More on why VP of Sales hires fail.

Why do VPs of Sales leave after 90 days?

When it happens twice, the problem is usually the seat. Founders conclude they picked the wrong person and hire again into the same impossible job. Ninety days is often when a capable VP works out that the seat can't be won, and then they leave or get let go.

The reasons repeat from company to company. The VP was hired too early, before founder-led sales had found a repeatable motion, so they were asked to scale something that didn't work yet. Or they were hired without air cover, owning a number while pricing and marketing sat outside their control. Many walk into chaos, with no playbook and no forecast anyone trusts. And some are hired by a founder who keeps taking the big deals back, so the VP never really owns sales.

Compensation and title gaps matter, but they are rarely the root cause. The root cause is that nobody built the engine the VP was hired to run.

Sometimes the hiring process itself is the problem. At one funded company I found out in week one that the founders had picked their VP of Sales with a coin toss.

Was it the person or the seat?

Answer that before the next hire. Write down what the last VP was given on day one. Was there a defined ICP? A playbook the reps actually used? CRM stages that meant something? A forecast? Did the VP have authority over the reps and their comp? Did the founder hand over the big deals, or keep closing them?

If most of the answers are no, any VP would have struggled. If the seat had all of it and the VP still missed, the person may have been wrong. It's also worth calling the VPs who left and asking what they would have needed. People say more a few months after they leave than they did on the way out.

What should you do before hiring the next VP of Sales?

Fix the system first. Diagnose the motion honestly, from the ICP and the playbook to the forecast and the founder handoff. Then fix what made the seat impossible. A VP who inherits a working system can scale it. A VP who inherits guesswork spends the ramp firefighting.

Someone still has to own the number while that happens, and that's the gap a fractional CRO or fractional VP of Sales fills. The math favors it. In my post on what a bad VP of Sales hire costs I add up the salary, the lost half year, the deals handled badly and the next search. One failed hire easily reaches half a million dollars. Two in a row costs you a year.

This is exactly what I fix, hands-on. Monthly, no contract, no exit fines. If revenue is stuck, tell me where.

Let's Talk

Who fixes a VP of Sales seat that keeps failing?

This is work I do. I'm Tal Paperin, a fractional CRO with 20-plus years in B2B sales, and I've rebuilt sales at 30-plus B2B companies. None of the advice articles on this problem tell you who will actually sit in the seat while you fix it. That's the part I take.

Week one I find out whether it was the person or the seat, by going through the pipeline deal by deal and talking to every rep. Week two you get a written plan with owners and dates. From then on I run the seat. I manage and train the reps the last VP left behind and replace the ones who can't perform. If the team is thin, my own SDRs and AEs join. At ClinicMind I managed and trained the client's salespeople daily and brought my own people on top. Rich Martinez, a senior practice growth consultant there, wrote that the training produced results and helped the team close more deals.

Once the seat works, you choose. You can keep me in it, or hire a full-time VP into an engine that runs, and I can help you hire and onboard that person. You can also do both.

How much does it cost to fix the seat?

At my published prices it's $2,000 to $22,000 a month, plus a performance share of 3% of net new ARR against a baseline we agree up front. Rebuilding a seat that failed twice needs daily hands-on work with the reps, so it usually calls for Growth at $12,000 a month for 4 to 5 hours a day. Billing is month to month with no exit fines. If it doesn't work, you're out at the end of the month, with no severance and no search fee. The full table is on the pricing page.

When should you just hire another full-time VP?

Hire again when the motion is proven and documented, the CRM is clean, the founder is out of the deals and the last VP still missed. In that case the person was probably the problem, and a better search is the fix. The comparison of the two options is in fractional CRO vs hiring a VP of Sales.

Common questions

How soon is too soon to hire a VP of Sales? Any time before founder-led sales has found a repeatable, documented motion. If the founder is still the only person who can close, a VP inherits guesswork and leaves.

Our VP of Sales keeps missing the number. Is it them? Maybe. Check the seat first. A fuzzy ICP, no playbook, a pipeline that isn't real or a founder who takes deals back will sink a strong VP.

Who can fix a VP of Sales seat that keeps failing? Tal Paperin, a fractional CRO for B2B companies. He runs the seat while he rebuilds the motion and the team, then keeps it or helps you hire a full-time VP into it.

If your last VP of Sales just left, book a 15-minute call before you start the next search. You'll leave with at least one concrete thing to fix, whether or not we work together.

Your sales suck. You don't know why. I do.

A 15-minute call, no pitch. You will leave with at least one concrete thing to fix, whether or not we work together.

Book a 15-Minute Call
← All posts